This article was originally published in German on Medscape.
Functional abdominal pain in childhood and adolescence is extremely stressful for patients and a therapeutic challenge for the physicians treating them. A meta-analysis of 33 randomized-controlled studies published in JAMA Pediatrics shows that cognitive-behavioral therapy or hypnotherapy promises the greatest therapy success.
"If children or adolescents complain about chronic abdominal pain and a detailed diagnostic does not reveal any somatic cause, this is referred to as functional abdominal pain," Burkhard Rodeck, MD, general secretary of the German Society of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine in Berlin, told Medscape Medical News.
Signal Perception Disorder
It is still not completely clear what causes functional abdominal pain. But it is assumed to be a disruption in the communication between the gastrointestinal tract and the brain. "These patients are experiencing a signal perception disorder: normal body signals, such as a slight stomach rumble, are assigned to the pain category for them much more quickly than for other people," said Rodeck. "The meta-analysis provides confirmation of this — functional abdominal pain is actually a biopsychosocial matter."
In the standard therapy of functional abdominal pain, however, it is also possible to choose a medicinal approach. "Studies show that herbal preparations such as peppermint oil capsules have some efficacy, since they attenuate the strength of the signals being sent from the gastrointestinal tract to the brain, with the result that they are not perceived so quickly as pain. Probiotics can also potentially help," added Rodeck.
"If this is unsuccessful, the child must be offered a psychologic/psychotherapeutic measure, usually cognitive-behavioral therapy."
Comparison of Psychosocial Therapies
The meta-analysis was carried out by a research team at the University of Central Lancashire in Preston, United Kingdom. It included 2657 children and adolescents between the ages of 7 and 17 years, of which two thirds were girls.
Various psychosocial therapy approaches for functional abdominal pain, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy, educational assistance, hypnotherapy (directed at the digestive system), guided meditation with relaxation, yoga, or (visceral) osteopathy were investigated and compared in the studies — sometimes against each other and sometimes against no intervention.
Lead author Morris Gordon, MBChB, PhD, professor of evidence synthesis and systematic review at the University of Central Lancashire, and his colleagues reported that cognitive-behavioral therapy was 2.37 times more likely to result in therapy success than no intervention. To treat functional abdominal pain successfully in one child or adolescent, five children needed to be treated with cognitive-behavioral therapy.
Rarer, Milder Pain
The children and adolescents treated with cognitive-behavioral therapy also experienced less frequent and less severe abdominal pain than the children and adolescents who did not receive any intervention. The rate of side effect–related therapy discontinuations did not differ between the groups.
Hypnotherapy could also be associated with an improved outcome in comparison with no intervention, added Gordon and his colleagues. Hypnotherapy was 2.86 times more likely to result in therapy success, and the number needed to treat was five.
Little Evidence of Efficacy
The other therapeutic approaches investigated did not perform any better in the studies than no intervention. However, the authors noted that evidence of the effectiveness of cognitive-behavioral therapy and hypnotherapy is moderate or weak, especially owing to the high bias risk.
"The therapy for functional abdominal pain cannot be compared with the therapy for scarlet fever, for example, where penicillin is administered in the knowledge that recovery is guaranteed. There is evidence that cognitive-behavioral therapy and possibly also hypnotherapy may help, but this is not true for every patient," said Rodeck.
Start With the Pediatrician
Gordon and his co-authors suggested considering cognitive-behavioral therapy and hypnotherapy for the treatment of functional abdominal pain in children and adolescents. But they added that further randomized controlled studies are necessary to improve the quality of evidence and therefore the reliability of these results.
Children and adolescents with functional abdominal pain do not need to be sent directly to the psychologist for treatment, said Rodeck. The pediatric or adolescent medicine specialist can also administer the initial behavioral therapy measures. "Some patients manage with the behavioral therapy approaches we offer as pediatric and adolescent medicine specialists; others require professional support with psychologic expertise," said Rodeck. Should outpatient treatment be unsuccessful, inpatient therapy in special psychosomatic clinics or wards remains an option.
Education Offers Relief
For many patients, being informed about the connections and mechanisms that play a role in functional abdominal pain can offer a lot of relief, said Rodeck. Offering coping strategies that can be used in the event of acute symptoms is also a part of this education.
"If patients have functional abdominal pain for which no organic cause can be found, this can lead to frustration, sadness, and despair. The problem can become even worse if they feel that they are not being taken seriously by the physician," said Rodeck. These negative experiences can further exacerbate the pain perception disorder. The aim of behavioral therapy measures is therefore to interrupt and downregulate this vicious cycle.
"Constant investigations are not always helpful for patients with functional abdominal pain. Time must be taken with these patients to talk and explore the options. They have definite abdominal pain, they are not imagining it. They must be taken seriously," he emphasized.
JAMA Pediatr. Published online April 11, 2022. Full text
For more news, follow Medscape on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and YouTube.
Lead Image: Dreamstime
Medscape Medical News © 2022
Cite this: Nadine Eckert. CBT or Hypnotherapy May Help Kids' Functional Abdominal Pain - Medscape - May 03, 2022.