US Surgeons Successfully Test Pig Kidney Transplant in Human Patient

By Nancy Lapid

October 20, 2021

NEW YORK (Reuters) - For the first time, a pig kidney has been transplanted into a human without triggering immediate rejection by the recipient's immune system, a potentially major advance that could eventually help alleviate a dire shortage of human organs for transplant.

The procedure done at NYU Langone Health in New York City involved use of a pig whose genes had been altered so that its tissues no longer contained a molecule known to trigger almost immediate rejection.

The recipient was a brain-dead patient with signs of kidney dysfunction whose family consented to the experiment before she was due to be taken off of life support, researchers told Reuters.

For three days, the new kidney was attached to her blood vessels and maintained outside her body, giving researchers access to it.

Test results of the transplanted kidney's function "looked pretty normal," said transplant surgeon Dr. Robert Montgomery, who led the study.

The kidney made "the amount of urine that you would expect" from a transplanted human kidney, he said, and there was no evidence of the vigorous, early rejection seen when unmodified pig kidneys are transplanted into non-human primates.

The recipient's elevated creatinine level returned to normal after the transplant, Montgomery said.

In the United States, nearly 107,000 people are presently waiting for organ transplants, including more than 90,000 awaiting a kidney, according to the United Network for Organ Sharing. Wait times for a kidney average three to five years.

Researchers have been working for decades on the possibility of using animal organs for transplants, but have been stymied over how to prevent immediate rejection by the human body.

Montgomery's team theorized that knocking out the pig gene for a carbohydrate that triggers rejection - a sugar molecule, or glycan, called alpha-gal - would prevent the problem.

The NYU kidney transplant experiment should pave the way for trials in patients with end-stage kidney failure, possibly in the next year or two, said Montgomery, himself a heart transplant recipient. Those trials might test the approach as a short-term solution for critically ill patients until a human kidney becomes available, or as a permanent graft.

The current experiment involved a single transplant, and the kidney was left in place for only three days, so any future trials are likely to uncover new barriers that will need to be overcome, Montgomery said. Participants would probably be patients with low odds of receiving a human kidney and a poor prognosis on dialysis.

"For a lot of those people, the mortality rate is as high as it is for some cancers, and we don't think twice about using new drugs and doing new trials (in cancer patients) when it might give them a couple of months more of life," Montgomery said.

The researchers worked with medical ethicists, legal and religious experts to vet the concept before asking a family for temporary access to a brain-dead patient, Montgomery said.

The so-called GalSafe pig was developed by United Therapeutics Corp's Revivicor unit. It was approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration in December 2020 for use as food for people with the red meat allergy known as alpha-gal syndrome and as a potential source of human therapeutics.

Medical products developed from the pigs would still require specific FDA approval before being used in humans, the agency said.

"Conventional thinking on alpha gal syndrome solely focuses on the food aspects," said Dr. Joseph Turek of Duke University in Durham, North Caroline, who was not involved in the NYU experiment.

Dr. Turek, a cardiac surgeon, has been studying the implications of alpha-gal allergies for patients receiving medical devices and pharmaceuticals derived from mammals.

"Up to 20% of people in certain regions of the country have immune reactivity to alpha gal," often caused by a tick bite that transmits alpha-gal into the body, he told Reuters. "Alpha gal syndrome is an emerging medical issue."

"Too many healthcare providers are unaware of this entity," he added. "My own interest in GalSafe pig-derived products is in heart surgery - I could see a number of products derived from the GalSafe pig that would be safer options than currently available medical products (heart patching materials and heart valves, in particular)."

Tasgola Bruner of People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) responded to the study in a statement, "Pigs aren't spare parts and should never be used as such just because humans are too self-centered to donate their bodies to patients desperate for organ transplants... Human organs are still the best hope, and presumed consent laws would make enough available to help people in need of a transplant."