New Insight Into COVID Vaccine Effects for Immune Vulnerable Patients

Peter Russell

August 24, 2021

There is a convincing case to support rolling out booster COVID-19 vaccines for some people with impaired immune systems to help optimise antibodies to SARS-CoV-2, scientists said.

The comments followed results from a study that suggested that a significant proportion of clinically at-risk patients with some immunocompromised or immunosuppressed conditions mount a low, or undetectable, antibody immune response after two doses of a COVID vaccine.

Initial data from the Observational Cohort Trial-T-cells Antibodies and Vaccine Efficacy in SARS-CoV-2 (OCTAVE) study has been reported in a preprint today.

It suggests that around 60% of patients in the study's groups mounted an immune response that looks similar to that seen in healthy control subjects. However, around 40% had a low or undetectable immune response.

The research, a multi-centre, UK-wide trial, led by the University of Glasgow, and co-ordinated by the University of Birmingham's Cancer Research UK Clinical Trials Unit, set out to evaluate immune responses following COVID vaccination in people with immune-mediated inflammatory and chronic diseases. These included inflammatory arthritis, diseases of the kidney or liver, cancer, and patients who are undergoing a stem cell transplant.

Preliminary Results

The early data, based on around 600 participants from a much larger cohort, was compared with that from 231 healthy people from the Protective Immunity from T cells in Healthcare workers (PITCH) study.

The researchers report that while all tested individuals in the PITCH study generated antibodies against the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein after two doses of either the Pfizer/BioNTech or AstraZeneca/Oxford vaccine, only 89% of patients within OCTAVE seroconverted 4 weeks after a second dose.

Antibody levels were dependent on the patients' disease. The percentage of patients responding less well than the lowest levels seen in healthy subjects was highest in those with:

  • ANCA-Associated Vasculitis patients treated with rituximab (87%)

  • Inflammatory arthritis (51%)

  • Renal failure on haemodialysis and immunosuppressants (42%)

  • Hepatic disease (36%)

  • Renal failure on haemodialysis (20.3%)

The lowest levels of patients with poor antibody reactivity were seen among patients with solid cancer (10%), and those with haemopoietic stem cell transplant (17%).

Prof Iain McInnes/SMC

Prof Iain McInnes, vice-principal of the University of Glasgow, who led the study, told a briefing hosted by the Science Media Centre: "The majority of the patients in the OCTAVE trial actually have mounted an immune response that looks remarkably similar to a healthy control group."

Furthermore, their outcomes were being compared with an "optimal group" consisting of people who were, on average, younger than the OCTAVE cohort.

He also stressed that even patients who mounted no antibody response after vaccination could be protected by a T-cell response.

"We're quite reassured that even patients on quite significant immune suppressive regimes are mounting this cell response, this T-cell response, and that gives us optimism that there is indeed a degree of virus protection, even for those whose antibody levels may be negative."

Booster Vaccine Study

Asked whether patients with an impaired immune system might benefit from a booster vaccine, Prof McInnes said: "Our data suggests that a booster for people who have mounted either an absent or lower level of antibody response would be a very reasonable next step."

The researchers had already begun a separate trial, called OCTAVE DUO, to address that question, he said.

It would involve patients randomised to receive either the Pfizer or Moderna vaccine, with a small sub-group given a third dose as a booster with the Novavax vaccine. 

'Comprehensive Study'

Commenting, Dr Doug Brown, chief executive of the British Society for Immunology, described the paper as "one of the most comprehensive studies to date" on the subject.

He said: "As we find our way out of the pandemic, we must keep researching how to optimise COVID vaccination schedules for patients with impaired immune systems to maximise future protection for these people. 

"This includes examining whether booster doses would be useful and looking into other therapeutic options for the small minority of patients who are unable to generate an immune response following vaccination."

Eleanor Riley, professor of immunology and infectious disease at the University of Edinburgh, said the research showed that many of the patients in the OCTAVE trial "did make a detectable antibody response, and their response went up again after the second dose of vaccine". It was, therefore, "quite possible that they will make an even better response after a third dose of vaccine", she said.

Examining the immunological effects of COVID-19 vaccination in patients with conditions potentially leading to diminished immune response capacity – the OCTAVE Trial, preprint


Comments on Medscape are moderated and should be professional in tone and on topic. You must declare any conflicts of interest related to your comments and responses. Please see our Commenting Guide for further information. We reserve the right to remove posts at our sole discretion.