Employed Doctors: Love the Paycheck, Hate the Rules

In This Article

The Impact of Gender and Age

More women doctors are employed than are self-employed: Among employed physicians, 38% are women and 62% are men; among self-employed physicians, 22% are women and 78% are men.

However, according to Sue Cejka, Managing Partner at Grant Cooper Healthcare, a physician/executive recruitment firm based in St. Louis, Missouri, this is more age-related than gender-related; there are more female physicians in the younger age category, while there are more self-employed docs in older categories. The dream and goal of private practice has lost allure to younger doctors, and of physicians under 40, employment beats self-employment (30% vs 12%); whereas over 40, fewer physicians are employed than are self-employed (49% vs 65%).

What Attracted Doctors to Employment?

The shift to employment among physicians has been on the rise in recent years. Estimates of employment range from about 25% to about 59%, depending on specialty, with about 50% of internists being employed.[1]

"Hospitals started the trend of buying up physician practices around 9 years ago," says Cejka. "Additionally, it's gotten much more difficult for independent practices to compete."

The challenges of private practice -- lower reimbursements, time spent on office management -- played a huge role in prompting more than a third of physicians (38%) to seek employment. Working shorter and more regular hours had the strongest pull for 29% of employed doctors, and not having to worry about billing and administrative issues was the key motivator for about 19% of respondents.

Some doctors noted other reasons as well: "I believe that the employment model reduces profit incentive in providing care"; "I love academic medicine and research in addition to patient care."

Once employed, the major benefit, cited by 58% of physicians, was not having to run the practice. Of note, getting a guaranteed income was ranked third, not first.

Respondents also cited these benefits: "academic opportunities"; "when I'm off, I'm off!"; "more vacation time and no loss of income during vacation"; "the chance to work with incredibly bright colleagues"; and "a chance to work with a world-class stroke team."


Comments on Medscape are moderated and should be professional in tone and on topic. You must declare any conflicts of interest related to your comments and responses. Please see our Commenting Guide for further information. We reserve the right to remove posts at our sole discretion.